Menu Close

Best Ice Cream in Kansas City in 2023

Last Updated on January 27, 2023 by admin

Best Ice Cream in Kansas City


Looking for the Best Ice Cream in Kansas City? Kansas is a holy city when it comes to dessert selection. It is mainly known for its barbeque outlets, but recent years have seen the rise of ice cream shops all around the city. Of course, the fact that there are an ever-present milk supply and fresh ingredients in the area is a significant contributing factor. Even better, the place is not in short supply for talent in making such
excellent ice cream flavors.

After your trip to the KC Steakhouse, check out our lists on –

If you want to taste some of the best ice creams in the nation, this list is set to guide you on your ice cream tour to the best of the best ice cream shops in Kansas City. From newly made flavors to some of the craziest flavors you would most likely never find anywhere, these shops will have a taste to tickle your sweet tooth to satisfaction.

Also, check out our list of Free Things to do in Kansas City.

#1 – Betty Rae’s Ice Cream 

Price range – 4.5 stars

Hours – 11:00 am to 9:00 pm.

Specialty – Ice Cream 

David Friesen and Mary Nguyen were the genii behind opening this ice cream shop. It has stood the test of time and became a fan favorite for ice cream lovers for over half a decade it has been in operation. Betty Rae’s was an easy choice for first on our list of the Best Ice Cream in Kansas City. What makes it stand out is that it is a friendly place you could go with your kids and the wide range of flavors they offer.

As of now, they have over 25 ice cream flavors, from the traditional flavors you may know like Strawberry and Vanilla off to newer ones. Some flavors like Lavender Honey have remained a favorite to its loyal customers since they opened the shop. It would be best if you also gave a try to some of their crazy flavor concoctions.

Recently, the shop website stated that they have new ownership with nothing else is expected to change at Betty Rae’s Ice Cream. The shop has been voted as the best ice cream flavor shop in the area several times and has a list of unusual flavors like The KC Burnt Ends and Sauce.

You can find Betty Rae’s Ice Cream shops in Waldo, 7140 WORNALL RD KCMO 64114, and the other at River Market, 412 DELAWARE ST KCMO 64105.

#2 – Paleterias Tropicana 

Price Range – 4.5 star

Hours – 8:00 am to 10:00 pm.

Specialty – Mexican Themed

Paleterias Tropicana has been in operation for over 15 years so far, and they have remained to be one of the best Mexican dessert servers in Kansas City. When they started, they wanted to serve the growing Hispanic market in the early 2000s and Best-Ice-Cream-in-Kansas-City-Imagebecome Michoacan-styled ice cream servers. Now it’s open for anyone with a taste of Mexican dessert, and you could either dine-in, get a takeaway, or have it delivered to you. 

They offer over 30 ice cream flavors that will sweep you right off your feet, whether made from milk or fruits. You are sure to find the most common ice creams like Strawberry, Vanilla, and Chocolate like you would expect. However, the Mexican flavors should be your go-to in a place like this. Plus, the shops are comfortable enough to be in and the service as friendly as they should be. 

What’s interesting about them is that they make your ice creams on-site. You can find a wide range of paletas like fruit chocolates, smoothies, agua frescas, shakes, and juices. Their flavors are one of a kind. The Tamarind with Chile and lime will satisfy your taste for the sour while still making sure that what you enjoy is sweet, and the Mongeneado might blow your mind. A great addition to our list of the Best Ice Cream in Kansas City!

You can find them at 151 S 18th St, Kansas City, KS 66102, 830 Southwest Blvd, Kansas City, MO 64108, 539 E Santa Fe St, Olathe, KS 66061, 2021 N Amidon Ave #115, Wichita, KS 67203

Also, check out our list of the best Parks in Kansas City!

#3 – Ice Cream BAE

Price Range – 3.8 star


Hours – Mon to Sat: 12:00 am to 9:00 pm and on Sundays: 12:00 am to 8:00 pm. 

Specialty – Eastern and Asian flavors. 

Ice Cream BAE is a place that has taken a different approach to ice cream selling compared to other ice cream shops in Kansas City. Their flavors are so different from what you would find in any ice cream shop. And the presentation might make you Insta famous. This is a result of their colorful cones and the way they do their toppings. 

Eastern and Asian ideas inspire their inspiration for their ice cream flavors. You could give a try to the Cinnamon Toast Brunch Milkshake, which has the Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal cinnamon rolls, Shatto Milk, and the vanilla bean ice cream. The shop allows you to pick out a flavor that you want and then pair it with two mix-ins blends. 

The shop owners Radisson Sichampanakhone and Jackie Faltermeier started Ice Cream, BAE, in 2018, and so far, they have been able to serve the whole city even with their limited number of stores. They make sure to use high-quality ingredients, and the location of the ice cream shop is best suited for a relaxation point during a hot shopping day. 

Just in case you were wondering why the owners named their shop BAE, well, you should know it stands for ‘Before Anything Else.’ Their ice creams prices are a bit steep compared to other ice cream shops in the area. An easy choice for our list of the Best Ice Cream in Kansas City

You can find them at 306 W 47th St, Kansas City, MO 64112. 

Afterward, check out our list of the Best Mexican Food in Kansas City!

#4 – Miami Ice 

Price Range – 4.5 star

Hours – 2:00 pm to 9:00 pm

Specialty – Shaved Ice and Syrup Flavors.

This shop is another ice cream place serving Kansas residents for years, now nearing the fourth decade in operation. They offer a wide range of choices that ice cream lovers could choose from, and they all come at affordable prices. It is an excellent place for those people looking to take a break from the creamy desserts. An easy choice for our list of the Best Ice Cream in Kansas City!

Miami ice is famous for the different syrup flavors they offer for their shave ice, and you could also try the soft serve options they have. Try out the tiger’s blood shave ice which is the best of two worlds. It is made from watermelon, strawberry, and coconut and comes with a soft serve that may leave you addicted to Miami Ice. 

The services at Miami Ice are nothing but exemplary. What’s more, you could get a photo or two for the gram while still in the location. It’s an excellent place for a family to get away with the kids and still lovely enough that even teenagers wouldn’t feel out of place to visit.

You can find them at 1624 W 39th St, Kansas City, MO 64111.

#5 – Foo’s Fabulous Frozen Custard

Price Range – 4 Star

Hours – Tue to Thur: 12:00 pm to 9:00 pm, Fri & Sat: 12:00 pm to 10:00 pm, Sun: 2:00 pm to 9:00 pm. 

Specialty – Custard.

Foo’s Fabulous Frozen Custard is a custard shop that can be said to have remained original to Kansas City. It has been in operation for over three decades now and has undergone many changes over time. From ownership to new menus being created, Foo’s Fabulous Frozen Custard is a place that guarantees to be worth the trip. 

The number of ice cream flavors that Foo’s place offers is wide and might turn you into a regular customer. Anyone could get something from Foo’s Fabulous Frozen Custard, given their diverse price ranges that differ with the different flavors. It is kind of sad that they no longer offer dine-in services or delivery. 

But you have a variety of places you could walk into and shop or have a pleasant stroll around the area as you enjoy your Foo’s ice cream. A favorite that we could recommend to those having their first visit to Foo’s is the BP3 and Stickey Hickey. The BP3 is a cake that will surprise you with its excellent taste of a brownie, peanut butter, and cake batter. On the other hand, the sticky hickey is a mixture of marshmallows, coconut, and chocolate chips. Last on our list of the Best Ice Cream in Kansas City!

You can find this ice cream shop at 6235 Brookside Plaza, Kansas City, MO 64113.

Picking the Right KC Ice Cream Shop 

Need help finding the Best Ice Cream in Kansas City? The number of ice cream shops available to Kansas City residents is not limited to this list, but the ones listed above will give you something that stands out. Getting to choose the right ice cream shop for you may be doubtful but considering what you want or expect from the shop is a big step towards choosing the right shop. 

If you are looking for a diverse collection of flavors that you want to try out from, you could try out Betty Rae’s Ice Cream shop. In case you want a break from the creamy deserts you are used to, you could try out the Miami Ice. Using the best ingredients they could offer, these shops give you flavors that might turn you into a regular client. These sure are the best places that could help you satisfy your sweet tooth.

We hope hour enjoyed our list of the Best Ice Cream in Kansas City!